Old Pulteney 2004 Single Cask #229
50.2% ABV - Highlands, Scotland
Nose: Sweet apple, flowers and orchard fruit. Salty. Biscuit and ginger cookies.
Taste: Melon, fresh fruit, pineapple, spices… and salt water taffy.
Finish: Sweet oak, spices, ginger, and long sweetness.
I probably had this bottle for way too long before I opened it. Checks the spreadsheet… Ah, it is true: I had the bottle for nearly five years before I finally opened it earlier this year!
Some of the first Old Pulteney whiskies that I tasted were these single casks. Big, punchy flavour—love it! When you develop a relationship with Old Pulteney at cask strength, there is some recurring disappointment when you taste lower bottling strengths of 43% ABV.
This bottle is an excellent value; a price from the good old days of 2018.
Details: Ex-Bourbon Cask. Distilled 2004; Bottled 08/08/2018. 1 of 281 bottles. Specially selected by BC Liquor Stores.
Tasting Notes (Official):Aroma: Intense and fragrant. Deliciously sweet toffee and honeyed vanilla deliver an indulgent welcome. Ripe fruits tempered by a hint of spice add lovely depth. Taste: Lively spiced liquorice and salty notes give way to a sweet burst of apple and citrus zest. A gratifying finish is enriched by butterscotch and chocolate.
Tasted 03 October 2023. (Posted 23 November 2023.)
85/100
Detailed Rating Information...
90+: Fantastic whisky; highly recommended.
My favourite whiskies – I might have more than one bottle if the price is right and the supply is limited! The higher values in this range will reflect a stronger balance and consistency between components.
85-89: Great whisky; recommended.
Whiskies that tick the flavour boxes and you'll likely hear about these from me. An easy decision to order at a bar/restaurant and one to consider buying a bottle of.
80-84: Very good whisky; recommended, but still consider trying before you buy.
Most of these whiskies I was really happy to have the opportunity to taste, but, apart from a dram here and there, I don’t think I would buy a bottle.
75-79: Good whisky; consider trying before you buy.
These are whiskies that I did enjoy drinking, but likely would reach for another bottle or select something different to order.
65-74: Average; consider trying before you buy, but not recommended.
There is nothing that stood out about this whisky and I might be inclined to mix it with soda or in a cocktail, instead of trying to enjoy its own flavours.
50-64: Bad; not recommended.
I didn’t like this and would sooner pass on another opportunity and order a beer instead than have it again… but never say never.