<ARCHIVE> | CAMPBELTOWN HIGHLANDS ISLANDS ISLAY LOWLANDS SPEYSIDE | AMERICAN CANADIAN IRISH WORLD | INDEPENDENT | ANCNOC ARDBEG BENRIACH BOWMORE BUFFALO TRACE CARN MOR COMPASS BOX DEANSTON DOUGLAS LAING FERMENTORIUM FORTY CREEK GLENDRONACH GLENMORANGIE HIGHLAND PARK JACK DANIELS JP WISERS JURA KILCHOMAN KNOB CREEK LAPHROAIG MACALLAN MIDLETON ODD SOCIETY OLD PULTENEY SHELTER POINT TWO BREWERS

Caol Ila 2003 G&M Sassicaia Wood Finish

45% ABV - Islay, Scotland

Nose: Mineral, very lightly peated – but it’s a dense cloud, some underlying sweetness and lighter florals, with candied or dried red fruits coming through. Subsequent sips brought slight citrus (grapefruit).

Taste: Smoke and peat are upfront dominant, followed by fruits, raisins, again a slight minerality, and topped by ginger and spices.

Finish: Citrus guides the smoke and ash, honey, spices, sourdough bread, and slightly drying or tannic.

This bottle from the Private Collection series by Gordon & MacPhail brings together two of my favourite things: Caol Ila and wine barrel finished (or matured) whiskey – in this delicious dram we have Sassicaia, the ‘Super Tuscan’ red wine,... and yes, Caol Ila, an inoffensive peated Islay malt.
It packs a comparable fruity punch as the Distiller’s Editions, but takes on some lighter flavours. Side by side comparison would be amazing! This near 13-year old Caol Ila spent its last 33 months in “the finest” ex-Sassicaia barrels. And, for comparison, the Distiller’s Edition spends in an unknown amount of time in ex-Moscatel.
I feel that I took a well-researched chance on this bottle; I knew I liked Caol Ila (a lot), and I was recently enamoured by an 8-year old Benromach finished in Sassicaia. Pulling the flavours of the ex-wine barrel (somewhat quite literally) and the gentle smoke of the peated single malt results in a near whisky-utopia!

Details: G&M Private Collection, 10/09/2003 - Aug 2016, 4000 Bottles.

Tasted 13 October 2018. Posted 05 December 2018.

91/100
Detailed Rating Information...

90+: Fantastic whisky; highly recommended.
My favourite whiskies – I might have more than one bottle if the price is right and the supply is limited! The higher values in this range will reflect a stronger balance and consistency between components.
85-89: Great whisky; recommended.
Whiskies that tick the flavour boxes and you'll likely hear about these from me. An easy decision to order at a bar/restaurant and one to consider buying a bottle of.
80-84: Very good whisky; recommended, but still consider trying before you buy.
Most of these whiskies I was really happy to have the opportunity to taste, but, apart from a dram here and there, I don’t think I would buy a bottle.
75-79: Good whisky; consider trying before you buy.
These are whiskies that I did enjoy drinking, but likely would reach for another bottle or select something different to order.
65-74: Average; consider trying before you buy, but not recommended.
There is nothing that stood out about this whisky and I might be inclined to mix it with soda or in a cocktail, instead of trying to enjoy its own flavours.
50-64: Bad; not recommended.
I didn’t like this and would sooner pass on another opportunity and order a beer instead than have it again… but never say never.


Whisky Bottle