<ARCHIVE> | CAMPBELTOWN HIGHLANDS ISLANDS ISLAY LOWLANDS SPEYSIDE | AMERICAN CANADIAN IRISH WORLD | INDEPENDENT | ANCNOC ARDBEG BENRIACH BOWMORE BUFFALO TRACE CARN MOR COMPASS BOX DEANSTON DOUGLAS LAING FERMENTORIUM GLENDRONACH GLENMORANGIE HIGHLAND PARK JACK DANIELS JP WISERS JURA KILCHOMAN KNOB CREEK LAPHROAIG MACALLAN ODD SOCIETY OLD PULTENEY SHELTER POINT TWO BREWERS

Aberfeldy 1995 G&M 24-Year

52.0% ABV - Highlands, Scotland

Nose: Granny Smith apples, white wine, rose petals, straw grass, green pepper, vanilla and celery root.

Taste: Ripe apples in an orchard with the sun shining right after rain. White pepper and sour candy.

Finish: Sweet honey, fruits, and spice with a light bitterness.

Nearly every other review on this website is for a bottle that I have bought and for a bottle that I’ve had at least a few drams from. This Aberfeldy before me probably only has a few drams left and that’s how I received it! You might have guessed but, yes, there is the proverbial heel of a whisky bottle. Every year, two of the local whisky clubs get together for a big buffet dinner and all of the heels from the tastings throughout the year are raffled off. My lucky number was pulled for this bottle of 24 year old Aberfeldy. (For those uncertain, a heel is the term used for a bottle of whisky that has about 3-4 pours left.)

I have not owned a bottle of Aberfeldy before—they generally are not to my taste preferences—so this is a really cool opporunity to be reviewing one. Further to its cool factor, Aberfeldy is very commonly aged in ex-Sherry barrels while this one here is fully matured in ex-American Oak.

Some bottles of whisky have a really defining characteristic that you could look at a flavour wheel and think, "A-ha! This is the definition of xyz." And, in this case, that xyz is apples—it is sooo apple-y. It reminds me of a Glenlivet or Glenfiddich… two whiskies of which I tend to taste a lot of fresh apple.

This is a bottle I wouldn’t have bought, and I am so thankful that I was able to taste it. Well, not only taste it, but sit down and spend some time swirling the flavours about and having a thoughtful malt moment with it.

Details: Bottled April 9, 2019. 220 Bottles. Batch 19/018. Refill American Hogshead.

Tasting Notes (Official): Aromas of baked apple and creamy vanilla combine with a refined floral edge. Thick and smooth; mouth-watering chilli flavours open into hints of fresh-cut grass. An elegant fruity finish.

Tasted 9 November 2023. (Posted 5 February 2024.)

88/100
Detailed Rating Information...

90+: Fantastic whisky; highly recommended.
My favourite whiskies – I might have more than one bottle if the price is right and the supply is limited! The higher values in this range will reflect a stronger balance and consistency between components.
85-89: Great whisky; recommended.
Whiskies that tick the flavour boxes and you'll likely hear about these from me. An easy decision to order at a bar/restaurant and one to consider buying a bottle of.
80-84: Very good whisky; recommended, but still consider trying before you buy.
Most of these whiskies I was really happy to have the opportunity to taste, but, apart from a dram here and there, I don’t think I would buy a bottle.
75-79: Good whisky; consider trying before you buy.
These are whiskies that I did enjoy drinking, but likely would reach for another bottle or select something different to order.
65-74: Average; consider trying before you buy, but not recommended.
There is nothing that stood out about this whisky and I might be inclined to mix it with soda or in a cocktail, instead of trying to enjoy its own flavours.
50-64: Bad; not recommended.
I didn’t like this and would sooner pass on another opportunity and order a beer instead than have it again… but never say never.


Whisky Bottle